openseo is the first: it fronts something that already ships an MCP server, and
the choice was to reimplement that vocabulary as Officer tools or hand the real
one over. Reimplementing means a second copy that goes stale, and it fails
silently — a tool exists upstream that Officer cannot see. Handing it over costs
one manifest field.
What a wrapper would have bought — authentication, logging, refusal — is already
true of the path, because the agent reaches it through Officer's own API with
Officer's own gate in front. Wrapping would buy it twice.
The manifest declares a PATH and never a URL, and that is the safety property
rather than a convention: mcp-host.json carries OFFICER_AUTH_TOKEN, which signs
as the owner, so a manifest able to name an arbitrary host would be a manifest
able to post the owner's credential anywhere. A path can only reach this machine.
Installed AND enabled, since a disabled plugin's routes are not mounted and
offering the agent a tool list that 404s is worse than offering nothing. A
plugin that cannot be read loses its tools for the session rather than stopping
the agent from starting.
`generateMcpConfig` becomes async because it now asks the database. Awaited, not
fire-and-forget: setMcpConfigPath is what the manager reads when it spawns, so a
config arriving later is an agent running without its plugin tools and no sign
of why.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
pastilhasandClaude Opus 5
912ecd04f7