putSecret/getSecret, `bun run secret:set`, and notify taking its credentials
from the store with env as the fallback. this was described two messages ago
as a later thing; it is about fifteen lines and it was blocking the honest
answer to "where does the .p8 go", so it is done.
getKey was the wrong door for anything supplied from outside — it MINTS a
random 32-byte value when the purpose is absent, which for a foreign
credential means silently authenticating to apple with a fake. getSecret
returns null instead, which is what lets the env fallback work.
putSecret retires the previous row rather than deleting it: a mistyped paste
over a working key should be recoverable, and retiredKeys already exists for
that shape. one transaction, because the partial unique index means the retire
has to land before the insert.
the CLI reads stdin and has deliberately no --value flag: a secret in argv is
in shell history, in ps output, and in any audit log that records command
lines. offering the flag would make the convenient path the leaky one. it
prints a length and the last four characters, never the value.
also `bun run notify:test`, which fires officer/core:test at a registered
device. the sidecar's port is ephemeral, so it now writes its address to
data/notify-server.url on boot and removes it on clean shutdown; the CLI
treats an unreachable address as "not running" rather than trusting the file,
because a crash leaves one behind.
the script says what actually happened, because the day-waster here is that a
send with nothing configured returns success and delivers nothing — it refuses
up front when channels is empty, and calls out sent:0/failed:0 as "no device
registered" rather than letting it read as success.
verified end to end with a p-256 key generated locally and then deleted from
the store: zero APNS vars in .env, sidecar reported channels: apns, and the
send reached the channel. store is back to jwt and offscale only.
env is the interim. the secret store's own reasoning applies almost verbatim:
bun auto-loads .env into every pm2 process, so the .p8 is readable from
/proc/<pid>/environ of twenty of them. officer-music has no business being
able to read a key that can push to the owner's apps forever and never
expires.
the obstacle is not a missing purpose string, which is what it looks like from
the outside. getKey(purpose) GENERATES a key and returns it — there is no
setter, because everything in the store so far is something the platform
minted itself. the .p8, the key id, the team id and the fcm service account
all come from outside, so this needs putSecret and a decision about who may
call it. same for DISCORD_WEBHOOK_URL and every plugin credential still in env.
recorded in TODO.md and in the design doc rather than left as an intention.
the sidecar now sends what the design describes.
producer contract: { code, userId, n?, id? }. validated on the SHAPE of the
code, never against the catalogue — a producer firing a code the mapping has
not caught up with is sending a real event, and dropping it here would trade a
degraded notification for none when the device already has a defined fallback.
the shape check still catches a typo at the producer instead of on a phone.
`ok` is gone. a failed job is its own code, officer/core:job-failed, which is
the thing the five-value enum could not express without a boolean bolted on.
apns: mutable-content: 1, alert.title fixed to the generic, and officer:{c,n,id,mv}
beside it. deliberately NOT the catalogue's title — sending the real text would
hand apple the category vocabulary in plaintext, which is what the code exists
to withhold.
fcm: data-only, no notification block. a notification block is rendered by the
system, which would put the code on the lock screen and give the app no chance
to resolve it. priority high is load-bearing — a normal-priority data message
can sit in doze indefinitely.
discord renders server-side from the catalogue, because it has no app to
resolve anything. safe: catalogue titles are templates and carry no user
content.
the catalogue is loaded ONCE per dispatch, not per channel or per device, so
every copy of one notification carries the same mv. two channels reading disk
either side of a plugin install would otherwise tell two devices different
things about the same event.
40 tests. verified live: a malformed code is refused, officer/core:test is
accepted and dispatches to zero configured channels.
the piece that makes a new notification kind a server change rather than an
app store release. a push carries a code and integers; this is what the code
means, synced to the device instead of compiled into it.
deliberately the same shape as affordances rather than a second mechanism: a
`notifications/` directory of yaml in the plugin repository, copied to
capabilities/notifications/<publisher>/<appName>/ on install, removed on
uninstall. publish.ts mirrors affordances/publish.ts closely enough to diff.
the namespace is DERIVED from where the file lands, never from what it
declares — same rule as mountPrefix. a plugin writing `officer/core:test` as a
key gets `<publisher>/<plugin>:officer/core:test` and the real core entry is
untouched. that is the security property of the whole scheme and it is pinned
by test.
version is a content hash, not a counter. a counter needs somewhere to live
and is then wrong after a restore, a rollback, or two servers built from the
same install; a hash needs no storage and is right in all three. so the client
compares mv !== version, and both docs now say so — i had written "higher".
core entries ship in code rather than on disk, because capabilities/ is
installed rather than committed and `test` has to exist on a machine that has
installed nothing — it is what first light is proved with.
read from disk per request, not memoised: installing a plugin has to change
the answer without a restart, or it presents as "the new plugin's
notifications don't work", which is the hardest kind of bug to place.
verified live: 401 through the platform, plugin catalogue appearing and
disappearing with no restart, version returning to its prior value when the
plugin is removed. 10 catalogue tests, 100% coverage of catalogue.ts.
three questions answered from monorepo-mobile, and two of my assumptions were
wrong.
bundle ids exist — dev.officer.mobile and dev.officer.mobile.dev. two of them
needs nothing special: push_devices is unique on (token, bundleId), so the
variants are separate rows on one phone, and the dev variant is exactly the
sandbox/production distinction the doc warned about. concrete now rather than
derived from build config by guesswork.
scheme is officer:// and officer-dev://, both from app.config.ts.
expo prebuild, not bare — and a config plugin that creates an ios app
extension target ALREADY EXISTS there, withVaultAutofillTarget.js for the
autofill extension. the nse follows it. that removes what i had called the
longest pole in phase 3.
corrected: expo-notifications is not in apps/mobile at all, only apps/chat.
the real blocker is narrower than the doc implied and is not code. today's
signed build has no aps-environment entitlement, and adding one fails while
xcode has no account signed in — same failure as the network extension on
2026-08-05. one manual sign-in, team RGHC4NJC77, then automatic again.
alpha: /api/notify was 404 all day because that server predated the work.
pulled, db:push, gen:ecosystem, officer-notify started, officer restarted.
verified 401 unauthenticated and push_devices with its 10 columns.
the 2026-07-31 design promised this document to `officer-suite/COMMS/`, a repo
path that has never existed. writing it where the work is instead, to be
handed to whoever builds the client.
exact contracts rather than prose: the three device routes with real request
and response shapes read off devices.ts, what is required versus defaulted,
and that the server takes the user from the session and ignores a userId in
the body.
most of it is the failure modes that cost a day each and are invisible from
the client — a send with no credentials configured returns success and
delivers nothing; a sandbox token registered as production fails at apple with
no user-visible symptom; the notification extension must not touch the network
or it will pass every test at a desk and fail on cellular with the vpn off.
leaves three questions for the owner: whether apps/mobile has a bundle id and
a provisioning profile at all, its url scheme, and expo managed versus bare —
that last one decides how the extension gets built and is probably the longest
pole in phase 3.
second design, superseding 2026-07-31. the reversals are recorded rather than
overwritten, because the first one called its payload rule "not optional" and
this changes it.
one app on the device receives everything and renders it. the payload is a
namespaced code plus integers; the code's meaning lives in a server-owned
mapping synced to the device ahead of time, so a new notification kind is a
server change and never an app build. plugins declare their own codes on the
affordances pattern, which already does exactly this shape.
what moved: privacy relaxed but not abandoned — codes keep content off apple
and google while dropping the rigid category enum that made the doorbell
painful. appSlug inverts from "deliver to this app" to "deep-link to this
app". extensibility becomes the binding constraint.
the piece that makes it work is that the ios extension does a LOCAL lookup
against a synced mapping, not a fetch on arrival — so it does not depend on
the tailnet being up when the push lands, and it costs one build ever rather
than one per kind.
records two things it does not solve: the code vocabulary is still a
fingerprint to apple and google, and the grapheneos/fcm contradiction between
apps/mobile/PUSH_NOTIFICATIONS.md and the platform design is still unresolved.
built 2026-07-31, switched off 2026-08-13 when it was slated to become a
plugin alongside memos and photos. those two were extracted; this one never
was, so it spent six days mounted nowhere with its schema commented out and
no pm2 entry — complete code that nothing could reach.
core rather than a plugin because the producers are the platform's own: the
job queue, an agent turn ending, mail arriving. a notifier the owner can
uninstall is one those producers cannot rely on.
- hono.ts mounts /api/notify again; verified 401 unauthenticated, so the
permission gate covers it and assertPermissionTotality accepts the mount
- push_devices exported from the core schema and pushed: 10 columns,
uq_push_devices_token_bundle, idx_push_devices_user
- officer-notify added to CORE_PROCESSES, so gen:ecosystem writes it
- credentials read OFFICERDEV_X ?? X, the convention it predates
safe as core because it boots with nothing configured: every channel reports
isConfigured() false and dispatch resolves empty. verified by importing it
with the env stripped — "channels: none configured", no throw. an install
with no apns key runs it as a no-op rather than crash-looping.
APNS_ENV is dropped from the doc's credential table. it was never read: the
host comes from each device's `environment` column, so one server pushes to a
testflight build and a release build at once.
doc status corrected. the app side is not started — there is no officer-suite
repo, no PUSH_NOTIFICATIONS_APP.md, and apps/chat actively strips the ios push
entitlement. recorded there rather than here.
DELETE /command-hq/commanders/:sessionId — deletes the transcript itself via
deleteClaudeSession (the same function DELETE /chat/sessions/:id calls, so a
/clear chain goes with it, every part), then the command_hq_sessions row via
deleteCommandHqSession (existing, exported, never previously called from a
route — its docstring said as much: "no product path to this yet").
Deliberately real deletion, not an unfile-back-to-/chat path — there still
isn't one of those, and this doesn't create one. Documented next to "The
/chat <-> /command-hq relationship" so it doesn't read as contradicting the
"a session never moves the other direction" rule directly above it.
Frontend: both the grid card and the detail bar's meta row get an inline
confirm (trash icon -> check/cancel), same shape as ChatHistory's own
SessionRow delete. The grid card's delete control is a sibling of the card's
<Link>, not nested inside it, per docs/navigation-audit.md — the card is a
stretched full-cover Link (absolute inset-0, default stacking) with the
delete control in its own stacking context (z-10) on top of it, so the card
stays click-anywhere except where the trash icon sits. Deleting the commander
currently open in the detail panel navigates back to the bare list rather
than leaving it pointed at a 404.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Traced "(no output yet)" on a live commander to the actual running process on
this machine rather than guessing: the tray's log-tail was working correctly
(it's a general /chat feature, nothing to fix there) — the task's .output
file was genuinely empty because the agent had written
`timeout 8 ping -c 1 -W 5 google.com >/dev/null 2>&1`, throwing away ping's
own output and only echoing on a failed ping. Correct for "let me know if it
goes down," but it means a healthy watcher shows nothing at all, indistin-
guishable at a glance from a stuck one.
buildBackgroundJobPrompt gains an unconditional rule — every job shape, not
only watchers — telling the agent not to redirect a command's own output to
/dev/null or similar: whatever it would print in a terminal is what the owner
wants to see live in the job's log. Landed at rule 8 for watchers (after the
existing fire rule), 5 for a bare command, 4 for a bare prompt — whichever
number falls after the rules already in that branch, so rule 7's existing
identity (referenced by number in tests, docs and COMMS) is untouched.
Also lightly reworded rule 7's "stay silent" line: it was already only about
the agent's own narration, not the underlying command's output, but the
distinction wasn't explicit and reads exactly like the instinct that produced
the >/dev/null in the first place.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The initial title (the mechanics preamble, truncated, when a background job is
the very first message) is expected — that's just Claude Code naming the
session from its first message, same as always. But by the time the watcher's
task actually starts, the harness has already handed it a real description
("Watch google.com reachability" for a ping watcher), and that reads far
better than the preamble ever will.
Hooked into the exact moment pendingArmWatcher is consumed — the FIRST arm,
never a self-re-arm, which the watcher-loop code already had to distinguish
for its own reasons. Resolves a fresh ChatIdentity via resolveHomeDir and
calls renameClaudeSession with msg.description. Best-effort: a failure is
logged and does not touch watcherArmed.
Known gap, noted in the doc rather than fixed: the detail panel's title bar
is fetched once on mount and won't live-refresh when this fires while it's
open. The grid's cards don't have this problem since GET /commanders already
polls every 15s.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Builds the Workspace/Panel screen the design doc's "Layout, v1" described but
nothing had implemented yet: /command-hq and /command-hq/:sessionId, three
always-mounted panels (officerdev/src/apps/CommandHQ/) — a flat category nav
filtering the grid via ?category=, a commander grid reading GET /commanders,
and a detail pane that is either an empty state, the new-commander composer, or
the selected commander's resumed transcript.
Follows the frontend route conventions in CLAUDE.md throughout: Workspace/Panel
framework (locked, three fixed panels, no standalone screen), category and
session both addressable in the URL rather than a channel, real <Link>s for
every row and card, a route pair (/command-hq + /command-hq/:sessionId) the
same shape as /chat's.
The composer reuses the exact mechanism /chat already uses to create a
commander — an ordinary turn with context: 'command-hq' via useChat/
EmbeddableChat — rather than the mobile-only POST /commanders/new HTTP route.
Once the harness reports a real transcript id the URL is replaced onto it
(useChat's own permalink writes /chat/<id>, which is the wrong screen here, so
that's done by hand). fileAsCommander always files a new commander
uncategorised — it has no way to know a category was selected in the composer
— so if one was, a client-side PATCH sets it after the fact, the same race
POST /commanders/new already resolves server-side for mobile, just resolved
here on the client instead.
The detail panel's transcript resume mirrors ChatPanelWrapper's fetch-then-
mount pattern (GET /chat/sessions/:id first, then useChat with
resumeSessionId + initialMessages + paginate) rather than reusing it directly
— Command HQ's version is simpler (no dashboard/agent-panel concerns) and
scopes rename/category/disarm through Command HQ's own PATCH route rather
than /chat's, since a commander lives in a different directory than an
ordinary chat session.
Card status is the three-state read COMMS/command-hq/mobile-4.md proposed and
the design record adopted: green running, amber armed-but-not-running (the
watcherArmed && !running pair that makes a silently-dead watcher visible),
grey neither.
Registered in AppRegistry.tsx, re-exported from officerdev's barrel (route
helpers + types, per CLAUDE.md's rule for anything an officer-web screen
needs), a CORE_DOCK_ITEMS tile (not in DEFAULT_DOCK_PATHS — opt-in via the
Dock settings screen, same as Jobs/Monitor/Activity), and a usePageTitle rule.
bunx tsgo clean, suite at its 7 pre-existing baseline failures, none of them
this feature's. NOT yet clicked through against a running server — the
composer's redirect-on-real-id, the disarm button, the category-race PATCH
have all typechecked and nothing more. That's the next real test.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The owner asked for individual turn token/dollar costs, a running total, cost
over time, and cost per trigger — derived, not stored, following the same
rule `running` already uses. Two new tables carry it:
- command_hq_watcher_fires: one row per trigger (sessionRowId, taskId,
firedAt). Replaces the single watcherLastFiredAt column, which lost the
previous fire's timestamp every time a new one landed — fine for "when did
it last fire", useless for "how many times, and what did each one cost".
- command_hq_turns: one row per completed turn (sessionRowId, fireId
nullable, inputTokens, outputTokens, totalUsd). Nothing pre-summed —
running total, cost-over-time and cost-per-trigger are all queries over
this table. Turn count needed no column either: COUNT(*) already answers
it, confirmed explicitly with the owner rather than assumed.
command_hq_sessions gains watcherArmedAt/watcherStoppedAt in place of any
"last fired" cache — set only on the false<->true transitions, so duration
(current run, or the last completed one) is computable without a full
transition history table.
Two new read routes, GET /commanders/:sessionId/turns and .../fires, expose
the raw series behind the cost summary and watcherLastFiredAt (now computed
via MAX(fired_at), not read off a column — the field survives in the JSON
response under the same name).
Bug found and fixed while wiring this up, recorded in docs/command-hq.md:
recordCommandHqWatcherFired's signature changed from (userId, sessionId) to
(sessionRowId, taskId) and one call site kept the old argument order —
tsgo stayed clean because number/string still matched structurally. Caught
by re-reading every call site by hand, not by any tool.
Needs bun db:push before any route answers with real data.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
second correction to the re-arm design tonight, and this one came from the
owner, not from me. my plan (platform sends a synthetic follow-up turn once
the acting turn's result lands, instructing re-arm) was technically sound —
it keeps the agent inside the sdk's own Monitor tracking, which is the thing
the FIRST wrong plan (silent respawn) broke — but it costs a real extra turn
every cycle. pushed back on with hard evidence: the mobile dev's own
watcher, on this repo, this session, had been running with THEM re-arming
themselves, same turn, for hours already — zero failures. that beats a
reliability concern I raised without having tested it.
so: handoffContract now instructs the agent to re-arm itself, as the last
action of the SAME turn that handles the notification — no synthetic turn,
no platform spawn, no extra cost. exitContract's handoff branch corrected to
match (was still saying "the harness re-arms a firing on its own", exactly
backwards now).
server side simplifies to match: createMessageHandler's task:started hook
now handles both cases with one rule — pendingArmWatcher (session-object
flag, not closure-captured, since arming happens turns after the closure
was built) claims the FIRST task:started as the watcher; every SUBSEQUENT
task:started while already armed is read as the agent's own self-re-arm and
just updates watcherTaskId to match. task:notification records the fire
when it matches the tracked id. the platform never drives anything — it
only notices what the agent already did.
pulled COMMS/command-hq/mobile-3.md, which answered the PREVIOUS (synthetic
turn) version — crossed in transit. their transcript-bloat concern is moot
now (no synthetic turn exists to bloat anything). their `watcherArmed &&
!running` detectable-failure pair stands regardless of which mechanism won
and is exactly right — kept as-is, matches their own three-state dot
(running/armed-but-not/neither). replied in platform.md.
all four proposal items now built: prompt+dialog, stopped-vs-died, the
re-arm mechanism (this commit), arming state+plumbing.
bunx tsgo clean, suite unchanged (1038 pass, same 7 pre-existing baseline
failures).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
item 4 first (schema + plumbing), ahead of the proposal's own suggested
order, because item 3's trigger needed somewhere to write to before it could
be tested at all.
command_hq_sessions gains watcherArmed/watcherTaskId/watcherLastFiredAt.
watcherArmed is allowed to be stored unlike `running` — it's the owner's own
intent, not a live-process fact nothing external can silently falsify the
way a sidecar restart falsifies running. armCommandHqWatcher/
recordCommandHqWatcherFired/disarmCommandHqWatcher in queries.ts, exposed on
GET /commanders, GET /commanders/:sessionId, and PATCH accepts
{watcherArmed:false} to disarm (arming itself has no route — needs a live
task id only a running turn has).
armWatcher threaded the full client-to-server path: BackgroundJobDialog ->
sendWithHiddenPrefix -> QueuedPrompt -> sendPrompt's new last param -> the
chat websocket message -> ClientMessage -> startClaudeTurn's msg. typechecks
end to end, consumed NOWHERE yet — safely inert, not a shipped mechanism.
the real finding: my plan to reuse task-restart.ts's restartBackgroundTask
for the actual re-arm trigger is wrong, and I caught it before writing it
rather than after. that function respawns a process OUTSIDE the sdk's own
Monitor tracking — chat.ts's restart route emits its own task:notification
via emitToSession specifically because the harness stopped watching that
process. it updates the ui; it cannot reach back into the agent's context,
because there's no mechanism by which it could. a handoff watcher needs the
opposite — the agent must be TOLD again when it fires again, which only
happens through the sdk's own notification delivery, which only exists for
a job the sdk itself is still tracking.
so re-arming can't be a silent platform respawn. it has to drive the AGENT
to reissue its own run_in_background/Monitor call — the platform's job is
making that automatic and correct (right command via commandForTask, right
moment, no double-arm), not doing the reissuing itself. likely shape: a
synthetic follow-up turn, not from the user, once the acting turn's result
lands. not implemented — raised with the owner before building around a
wrong assumption a second time tonight.
docs/command-hq.md corrected to match — the earlier "reuse restartBackgroundTask"
claim removed and replaced with what's actually true.
bunx tsgo clean, suite unchanged at baseline (1038 pass, same 7
pre-existing failures).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
owner's call, confirmed 2026-08-18: implement watcher-loop-proposal.md
exactly as written, before the first real tests — this governs agent
behavior generally, not just command hq. items 1-2 of the proposal's own
suggested order, done; items 3-4 (harness-owned re-arm, arming state on the
commander row) are the harder half, next.
FireBehavior replaces the stopOnFire boolean: 'stop' | 'handoff' |
'keep-going'. handoff carries the proposal's one-sentence contract verbatim
("the harness re-arms you — do not re-arm yourself, and do not build your
own polling loop on top of this one") and rewrites the closing IF IT EXITS
block so it stops contradicting rule 7 (the old universal "do not restart
it, i will start it again" directly lied about what handoff jobs actually
do).
isCommander gates the option to where the promise can be kept. the proposal
frames this entirely in terms of commanders — arming state's only home is
the commander row — so outside one there's nowhere to persist "keep
re-arming this," and offering the option there would make a promise nothing
fulfills. not wired to true anywhere yet: command hq's own composer, which
would set it, doesn't exist. every existing /chat caller is unaffected —
two options, stop default, unchanged from before tonight.
stopped-vs-died (§5): a job officer had just SIGTERM'd came back
status:'failed' (exit code 144) from the harness's own classification,
which this codebase does not control. fixed client-side — the tray already
knows the instant stop is clicked, so it now also marks that, and
useChat's task:notification handler overrides the displayed status
regardless of what the harness reported. known gap, stated in both the code
and the doc: in-memory, so it doesn't survive a refresh in the narrow window
between clicking stop and the notification landing.
docs/command-hq.md gains "the watcher loop" section: what's built, what
isn't, the proposal's own suggested order followed as given.
bunx tsgo clean. suite: 1038 pass (+9 new tests), same 7 pre-existing
baseline failures.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
mobile-2.md found it: a commander created to become a background job sends
buildBackgroundJobPrompt's full mechanics as `prompt` — a page of preamble,
the owner's actual sentence only at the end — and command_hq_sessions has no
name column, so the title comes straight from `(displayText ?? prompt).slice(0,100)`.
without it every such commander titles itself with the mechanics text, and
the grid becomes a column of identical unreadable cards. same precedence the
websocket path already uses on both clients (sendWithHiddenPrefix on web,
useSessionView.ts on mobile) — now the same on this endpoint too.
fixed before either side had run this against a real server, so there's
nothing to clean up on a live grid.
also confirmed rather than assumed, per mobile's other note: cwd cannot be
talked into a different one on this path. resolveChatCwd's command-hq branch
ignores msg.cwd unconditionally and this endpoint never sets it.
replied in COMMS/command-hq/platform.md. also read watcher-loop-proposal.md
(exit/act/drain/re-arm as harness infrastructure, "Andre's call" to build it
before first tests) — not starting it off a COMMS note alone, taking it to
the owner directly since it's a real scope addition beyond what tonight's
command hq build was scoped to.
bunx tsgo clean, suite at baseline.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
mobile's need, decided with the owner in COMMS/command-hq/mobile.md, now
built: { prompt (required), categoryId? } -> { sessionId, cwd }, sessionId
being claude's REAL transcript id, not a placeholder.
the owner confirmed prompt is required and described why: a commander
usually starts as an ordinary back-and-forth before a background job is ever
armed via the existing dialog, sometimes it's just "you know what to do" —
either way there's always a real first message, same as any conversation.
no empty-commander case to design around.
getting a real transcript id costs actually starting the turn, since claude
assigns one only once system.init has been reported. extracted the
turn-starting half of handleClaudeCodeChat into startClaudeTurn(ws: ... |
null, ..., onOutcome?) so both the websocket path and this endpoint drive
one spawn function instead of two that drift — handleClaudeCodeChat is now
a thin wrapper with an unchanged signature. onOutcome mirrors every
sendToClient(ws, {type:'error',...}) refusal point (member not signed in,
claude not installed, spawn failure) plus the session:claude success case,
so an http caller gets the real reason instead of a generic 30s timeout.
the category-write race: fileAsCommander (same hook the web path uses,
since context: 'command-hq' is set either way) always files with no
category. the endpoint's own createCommandHqSession is upsert-safe
regardless of which insert wins, and an unconditional setCommandHqSessionCategory
UPDATE runs after — always last, always wins, so the requested category is
what's left standing no matter the race.
said plainly in COMMS/command-hq/platform.md: this refactor of live spawn
machinery did not get the second-pair-of-eyes review i said i wanted before
touching it. bunx tsgo clean, suite at the same 7 pre-existing baseline
failures. not exercised against a running server on either side yet.
docs/command-hq.md updated throughout — API table, "how a commander is
created", "still open" now empty of blockers.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
`context: 'command-hq'` on a chat websocket turn now resolves to
getCommandersDir(email) regardless of any client cwd, and the row gets
written the moment a real transcript id is known — the same
session:claude/result seed chat_session_models already waits on, a sibling
closure (fileAsCommander) hung off the same two triggers.
found while wiring it, not guessed at: a member's commander turn would have
failed to spawn at all. getCommandersDir is a sibling of home, and
confineUserTree confines every sibling of home to 700 owned by the service
user — unreachable "even by name" — which is exactly wrong for a directory a
member's own turn needs to cd into via setpriv. same shape of bug
resolveChatCwd already tells a story about (general_chat_sessions,
abandoned for the same reason). fixed by chowning commanders/ to the member
the same way confineUserTree already chowns home, and excluding it from the
loop that confines every other sibling. no ACL needed, unlike home — command
hq reads a member's transcripts through listTranscriptsAs, the same
as-the-member read /chat already uses, never as the service user directly.
the gap this leaves: an account provisioned before this commit needs one
manual reprovision (provision-linux-route.ts / manage-users.ts, already
idempotent) before its first commander turn works. documented, not silently
left.
pulled COMMS/command-hq/{mobile,watchers-what-broke}.md from the mobile
side's session — apps/commandhq already exists and typechecks against the
router. their finding: mobile cannot create a commander the way the web
composer does (a context flag two independent clients would have to carry
correctly), and decided with the owner on POST /command-hq/commanders/new
instead. not built server-side yet — the real blocker is that claude does
not assign a transcript id until a turn actually runs, so the endpoint has
to run one and wait for session:claude, which means extracting the
turn-starting half of handleClaudeChat rather than a second copy of it.
replied in COMMS/command-hq/platform.md with the two open questions before
building it (prompt omitted, and wanting a second look at that refactor).
docs/command-hq.md updated throughout to say plainly what's built vs planned
per path (web vs mobile) rather than one blended status.
bunx tsgo clean. suite at baseline (same 7 pre-existing failures).
confineUserTree has no unit tests today (sudo/uid-dependent, matching this
file's existing coverage posture) — not inventing a new harness for one
block inside it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
full REST surface for categories, tags and commanders. core permission
(personal: ['/'], no grant to hold — every query is scoped to the caller's
own user_id at the sql layer regardless). registered in the permission
registry and PROTECTED_MOUNTS together, so totality holds by construction.
GET /commanders is the grid endpoint: everything /chat/sessions already
returns per session, plus categoryId/tagIds/running. `running` is derived
live off collectRunningTasks (now exported from websocket.ts) folded over
chat_session_events — not a stored column, on purpose, matching the design
doc's stance that a status field would go stale exactly when a sidecar
restart silently kills a watcher.
GET /commanders/:sessionId deliberately does NOT duplicate the transcript —
that stays GET /chat/sessions/:id, unchanged. a client calls both.
/chat/sessions now excludes anything filed as a commander (listCommandHqSessionIds,
.catch()'d so a hiccup on this feature can't take the whole chat list down)
— the other half of the one predicate this whole design turns on.
there is deliberately no POST /commanders/new: creation is an ordinary chat
turn in the commanders directory, which is the next commit.
docs/command-hq.md gains an API reference table for the mobile dev, and a
status line at the top saying plainly what is real and what is not yet:
needs `bun db:push` before any route returns real data, frontend not
started.
bunx tsgo clean. suite at baseline (same 7 pre-existing failures, all
registry/totality drift and the pty socket test — none touch this router).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
first commit of command-hq/command-hq.md's design. two tables plus a
many-to-many for tags, no server surface yet — this is data layer only.
command_hq_sessions has no name column: /chat never persists a title to
postgres, renameClaudeSession appends a summary entry straight into the
transcript's own jsonl, and that stays the ONLY place a commander's name can
live. no status column either — liveness is derived from chat_session_events
the same way the background-job tray already derives it, because a stored
status would go stale the moment the harness sidecar restarts without a
final task:notification and nothing would ever correct it.
category is a plain FK (one per commander, confirmed in spec); tags are the
many-to-many case, schema only, no ui planned yet.
also: getCommandersDir(email) -> DATA_PATH/<email>/commanders, one shared
directory for every commander a user has. the first design was per-commander
directories and was dropped same-night: creating a fresh directory timed
against the harness's own spawn is a race, and a shared pre-existing
directory removes it instead of handling it. deliberately DATA_PATH-rooted
even for the owner, unlike ordinary /chat which runs in the owner's real
home — that's what keeps commanders out of both the owner's own project
transcripts and the /chat list.
bunx tsgo clean. no db:push yet — next commit is the router, and the table
needs to exist before anything can call it; will note the push requirement
clearly when that lands.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
the owner confirmed it live the same day. what that leaves untested is the
half the cache exists for — a second login, the tabs, a stored row surviving
a switch — so the docs now say which half is proven instead of claiming
neither is.
also records the bug the first deploy found, since the doc had asserted the
degradation that turned out to be broken.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
it has never run: db:push has not been applied and neither process has been
restarted. docs/ai-usage-panel.md records where every number comes from and
why officer cannot derive any of them itself, the two things the live
payload settled (every model-scoped bucket is null while limits[] carries a
real fable window; the window is named by kind, never by the model name),
the measured costs, and the staleness rules — which are the part most likely
to be wrong, because they assert things about data they did not measure.
sixteen ordered tests in five groups. group C is the actual feature. test 10
is the one that would break silently: a refresh must not overwrite an
account it could not measure.
also records what the scan measurement found, since it decides the deferred
work — 74.7% of message ids appear in more than one transcript file, so
per-file aggregates cannot be summed and an incremental scan is not the
one-liner it looks like.
TODO.md gains an entry under "waiting on the owner to run it", beside plan
mode, which is also still unexercised.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
half of the primitive kiosk needs. the manifest field and its validator are in;
the mounting is documented and not wired, so nothing serves anything publicly
today.
paths are relative to the plugin's own mount and refused rather than corrected:
no leading-slash-missing, no .., no //, no query or fragment, wildcard only as a
trailing /*, and never the bare / or /*. the plugin is trusted with what those
paths DO, never with which paths.
the mounting was measured rather than reasoned about, and two obvious designs
are wrong:
mounting the public router at the plugin prefix gives correct fall-through but
lets the router serve any route it defines - the manifest becomes documentation
rather than enforcement.
adding a use('*') guard blocks that leak and BREAKS the plugin's authenticated
api: a use('*') middleware always matches, so the parent never continues.
measured - an authenticated route 404'd with a valid token.
what works is registering only the declared patterns, delegating into a
pre-mounted app. undeclared paths never register a handler, so they fall through
naturally. enforcement by registration rather than by checking, which is why a
plugin cannot widen it.
docs/plugin-unauthenticated-paths.md has the probe results and the six
remaining steps.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
a sweep for remnants after 2026-08-18. nothing was broken - no dangling
import, symbol, route or permission key anywhere in src/ - but the platform
was still speaking the plugin's vocabulary in a dozen places.
the one that mattered is live code rather than prose: ChatPanelWrapper
hardcodes workspace.id === 'email' to send context: 'email', which is the
frontend half of the pair whose backend half (resolveEmailCwd) carries a
fifteen-line justification. the two ends now both say so, including that
adding a SECOND id there is the signal the platform needs a real way for a
plugin to declare a chat context.
the rest: two dead imports left by removing the settings section, an empty
'Email' type-section header, a protocol.ts section header with no members
naming the plugin's SSE design, and a queue comment pointing at
sidecar/email/sync-runner.ts - a path in another repository now.
CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md and working-on-officer.md described email as a platform
feature, an app permission and a pm2 process. those are the files a fresh
agent reads first, so they were the highest-risk staleness in the tree.
TODO.md's whole Email section moved to the plugin's own repository. it held
OPEN items pointing at sidecar/email/store.ts, which is exactly how a leftover
list sends someone to edit files that do not exist.
the delete-account dialog promised it would remove email accounts and
playlists. both tables belong to plugins now, so that cascade only happens
where the plugin is installed - it now says 'anything an installed plugin
keeps for them' instead of naming two it cannot guarantee.
imapflow and mailparser STAY in package.json. the plugin has no package.json
of its own and resolves from the platform's node_modules, so removing them
would break the installed plugin's sidecar. the fix is giving plugins their
own dependency manifest, not deleting these.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
the owner has no time to test any of it, so the checklist has to work for
someone with none of today's context: eleven ordered tests, what each should
show, and what its failure looks like.
test 4 is called out as the one most likely to be wrong - approving
ExitPlanMode drops the harness into default rather than back into
bypassPermissions, which is the finding that changed the design and therefore
the thing the implementation is most likely to have got wrong.
also separates what was verified from what was not: the probe runs against a
real claude, the turn-stream unit tests, and then everything end to end, which
is nothing.
the inline 'what to watch' list in chat-plan-mode.md is replaced by a pointer
so there is one source of truth, and TODO.md now says live-but-unexercised
rather than built-not-run - the restarts are done.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
the owner confirmed the additional accounts are test rows - none has ever
signed in, no member has opened a shell or a chat. so the proxy secret was
readable by accounts that do not exist in practice, and there is nothing to
rotate.
the mode fix stands: it is about the install that gets used, not this one.
dropping the TODO and recording the reasoning instead, because a rotation item
left sitting there reads as outstanding work forever, and the next person to
find a world-readable secret should ask who uses the box before reaching for
the alarm.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
data/sidecar/claude-state.json holds proxySecret, and that string IS the
owner's Claude Max subscription: officer-anthropic-proxy accepts it as
x-api-key, swaps it for the owner's OAuth bearer and forwards to
api.anthropic.com. it listens on 127.0.0.1, which every local account can
reach.
it was 664 in a 775 directory. nothing had ever set a mode - mkdirSync and
Bun.write at ubuntu's default umask of 002. confirmed by reading the live
secret as 'nobody', an account with no relationship to the platform, and by
confirming the proxy 401s without the key so the secret is the only control.
this does NOT mean members shared the subscription. spawnClaudeAsMember runs
their claude through setpriv --reset-env with a six-name allowlist, so
ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL and ANTHROPIC_API_KEY cannot cross into it and their turns
go straight to anthropic on their own OAuth. that design is intact - it could
just be walked around by anyone with a shell.
fixed twice on purpose. state.ts sets 0600/0700 on every write, which is the
authoritative fix, and on every write rather than at creation because
writeFileSync leaves an existing file's mode alone. secureRuntimeSecrets()
sweeps at boot because officer-anthropic-proxy is a separate pm2 process that
can recreate the file hours after officer started, and because every existing
install has the old mode until something repairs it.
it repairs rather than refusing to boot, unlike assertSecretsClosed beside it.
the line is who wrote the file: .env is the installer's and we must not guess
at it; this is our own output at the machine's umask, so refusing to start
would punish the user for our bug.
the per-account copies are swept too. no live secret in them today, but they
map session keys to transcript uuids for named accounts.
tests verified to bite: removing the chmod while still reporting success fails
four of them.
a chmod does not undo exposure - the secret still needs rotating on the
production host. TODO.md has the sequence, including that officer-claude-code
caches it and must be restarted alongside the proxy.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
opusplan is in the picker and does nothing on this install: it is a per-MODE model switch (Opus while in
plan mode, Sonnet at rest — the CLI's own strings call them the upgrade and resting models), and
claude-manager hardcodes permissionMode: 'bypassPermissions', so plan mode is never entered. Not
orchestration, which is what the name suggests and what we both assumed.
Making the mode reachable is the fix. setPermissionMode is a control request on the live query, same channel
as the setModel that landed in 4c24df93, so the mechanism is proven. The hard part is ExitPlanMode: it is a
permission decision, and bypassPermissions auto-approves it, so a naive toggle produces a planner that
instantly approves its own plan. canUseTool is the hook, and whether it can be supplied after session
creation is the one thing to verify before designing any UI.
Records the landmines too — bypassPermissions is deliberate per CLAUDE.md and must be restored on exit, and
a canUseTool promise that never resolves wedges the turn.
`createMessageHandler` is built per turn, so `transcriptId` started null on every one — and
`applyModelChange` runs before the turn emits anything, so the `model:switched` it produces arrived while
there was nothing to key the row on. A resumed conversation therefore recorded its model only on the closing
`result`, and a turn that died took the switch with it.
Observed rather than reasoned: the sidecar log said `claude-code/fable -> claude-code/opus[1m]` while the
stored row still said `claude-code/opus`.
Seeded from the resume id, which the Claude path already has in scope for the spawn. A brand-new
conversation still waits for `session:claude` — it has no id yet by definition — but resumed is the case
where switching actually happens.
Also lands docs/chat-sessions-list.md: the plan of record for the sessions-list revamp, agreed with the owner
today. Six numbered targets, four decisions with their reasoning, and the landmines — chiefly that merging
the two left-column panels strands `chat-live` in every persisted layout, which is the same stale-appType
shape that made /offscale render three server pickers this morning (ed3806f9). Written down because the shape
came out of a conversation, not out of the code.
Asked for a thorough check that nothing of offscale is left in the platform. The
extraction was sound — no router, no permission entry, no app-store entry, no
screen, no panel app, no env var anything reads. Two things were genuinely wrong,
and both were in setup rather than in the server.
── The secret store minted a key for a plugin ──
`officer-setup` bootstrapped two purposes: `jwt` and `headscale`. The second was a
key for a PLUGIN, under a name the rename had already replaced, on a machine where
the plugin is not installed and nothing would ever ask for it. offscale encrypts
under `offscale`, and `getKey` creates on demand — which is precisely what lets
core know nothing about plugins. Now core bootstraps `jwt` alone.
── `.env.example` documented variables for a deleted router ──
HEADSCALE_URL, HEADSCALE_API_KEY and HEADSCALE_USER were described as driving
`/api/vpn`. That router was deleted on 2026-08-14 and nothing has read any of them
since. Left as a note saying where the tailnet's credentials live now, because
somebody with an older `.env` will otherwise wonder why setting them does nothing.
── Names that outlived the thing ──
Eleven comments referred to the plugin's route, panels, console or server registry
as "headscale": three sidecar config files describing their own shape by pointing
at it, two screens citing `/headscale` as the example of a Workspace/Panel route,
the terminal's note about the Console, and the photos types. Also `catalogue.ts`,
which still claimed headscale "is CORE now", and `working-on-officer.md`, which
told the reader a core install runs six processes including `officer-headscale`.
Upstream references are deliberately untouched: "Headscale's API", "the Headscale
admin credential", "is this a Headscale server?" all name the thing the plugin
drives, and renaming those would make the sentences false.
`docs/secret-store.md` argued headscale must be core because the tailnet is the
perimeter. Marked superseded rather than deleted, with the distinction that
settles it: the perimeter is the tailnet EXISTING, which machine-setup still
arranges on a core install — not the platform shipping the screen that
administers it.
Verified by counting: live code, setup provisioning, env references, permission
entries, app-store entries, hono mounts, dock defaults, screens and panel apps all
zero. What is left is generated files (Plugins.gen, plugin-schemas.gen), the
bundled catalogue entry, test fixtures using "offscale" as an example app name,
and history.
tsgo clean, frontend builds, 873 pass / 7 fail unchanged, setup scripts parse.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This bug will not be reproduced on demand. It will arrive as somebody's report,
hours later, from a browser whose console is long gone — so a `console.warn` is
seen by nobody, and "what did you see?" gets an answer built from memory and a
screenshot.
So the trap now persists. Up to five occurrences in
`localStorage['officer:editor-buffer-trap']`, each carrying the stack at the moment
of the edit, the first 200 characters that arrived, how many, which file, and when.
The question becomes "paste this key", and the answer is complete.
Recording a bug must never become one: private mode, a full quota and a disabled
storage API all throw at that write, and none of them is worth breaking an edit
over. The console line survives either way.
`docs/editor-buffer-corruption.md` is the procedure — what it looks like, the four
candidates already eliminated and why, the one command to ask a reporter for, how
to read each field, what an EMPTY key would mean (either the editor was focused,
making it a paste, or the insertion came in chunks under the threshold), and the
instruction to delete every piece of this once the cause is known. Linked from
TODO.md and from CLAUDE.md's reading list, so somebody handed a report finds it
without grepping for it.
Stated there rather than left implicit: a fix invented without knowing the cause
would hide the symptom on the one screen where it is visible while the mechanism
carried on doing whatever else it does. The corruption is never saved and reopening
the tab clears it, so waiting is cheap and a wrong fix is not.
tsgo clean, frontend builds, 873 pass / 7 fail unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Split out of docs/marketplace.md so the design document stays about how it works.
Ranked by what blocks something rather than by size: submissions first (until a
stranger's manifest can be read without executing it, the catalogue is ours only
and everything below is cosmetic), then plugin upgrades not migrating, then
staleness, then scale.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The site is up on HTTPS with a Let's Encrypt certificate, proxied to :9100, and
serving the three plugins out of `officer_marketplace`. An Officer install with no
configuration now reads its catalogue from it.
── What is running ──
PM2 entry added to THIS machine's ecosystem only. Deliberately not in
officer-setup's CORE_PROCESSES: the marketplace is one website officer.dev hosts,
not something every install should run — a copy on every machine would serve a
stale catalogue on a port nobody asked to open.
nginx (NPM host id 7) → 172.20.0.1:9100, with a ufw rule for the docker bridge.
That rule is not optional and its absence does not look like a firewall problem:
without it nginx HANGS until proxy_connect_timeout rather than being refused,
which is how the apptest hosts wasted an hour a few days ago.
── READMEs ──
`music`, `offscale` and `example` now have proper READMEs, written against their
own code and pushed to their own repos. They render on the plugin's page in the
store and are what a self-hoster reads before installing. The example's is a
tutorial as much as a shop window — it is the document a plugin author reads
first, and every convention in it was verified in `discover.ts` rather than
restated from memory.
`music`'s remote was HTTPS with no credentials on this box, so it could not be
pushed; switched to SSH like the other two. The catalogue still advertises HTTPS —
`marketplace-sync` converts — which is the property that matters, since an
`ssh://` clone URL only works on the machine that published it.
── Writing them was the cheapest audit available ──
Reading each plugin against its own documentation turned up ~20 real defects, all
recorded in TODO.md and none fixed here. The pattern worth naming: offscale is
still branded "headscale" in user-visible panel names and in a persisted terminal
session id, and its PLUGIN.md states outright that the ACL assistant is
deliberately unwired — while `sidecar/assist.ts`, `claude-proxy.ts` and
`PolicyAssistant.tsx` all ship. Documentation that confidently describes the
opposite of the code is worse than none.
Also fixed the docs on the frozen lockfile: both CLAUDE.md and bunfig.toml named
`bun install --no-frozen-lockfile` as the escape hatch, and bun 1.3.14 has no such
flag — it is ignored and the install fails anyway.
tsgo clean, 873 pass / 7 fail unchanged.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
44 files of prose — CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md, TODO.md, 20 docs, both plugin design
documents, and the comment surface the earlier steps could not reach.
Applied against an explicit keep-list, not swept, because the word turned out to
have SIX meanings in this repository rather than the three the offscale doc
recorded:
permissions renamed (steps 1–2)
$OFFICER_ROOT/capabilities/ KEPT — the item store, and now the only thing
the word means that is ours
sidecar routing keys renamed to `handles` (step 3)
Lightning wallet KEPT — a domain term, and on the wire to the mobile apps
terminfo queries KEPT — XTGETTCAP, in the pty sidecar
InvoiceShelf KEPT — per-resource { write, bulkDelete } flags
The sweep still falsified two things, both caught by checking rather than by
review, and both in prose that discusses more than one meaning at once:
CLAUDE.md began claiming the item store lives at `$OFFICER_ROOT/permissions`.
It does not; that directory is on disk and full of skills and tools.
And the offscale doc's own note about the collision became
"Named `permissions`, NOT `permissions`" — a sentence that had eaten the thing
it existed to warn about.
Both restored, and the note rewritten to say what is now true: capability means
one thing of ours, and three that belong to somebody else's vocabulary.
Verified live after restart: self and admin permission endpoints 200, gated
route 200, agent-status 200, 9 grants intact with 6 permissions offered.
tsgo clean, 797 tests, 787 pass, same 7.
The rename is done. Four steps, no data lost, no client break that survived
the step it was introduced in.
docs/offscale-plugin.md becomes plugins/offscale/PLUGIN.md. most of it is about
the plugin system generally rather than about offscale, which is exactly why it
belongs with the worked example — the reasoning is most useful beside the code
it produced, and the platform's docs should not carry the history of something
it no longer knows exists.
every reference updated.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
offscale had no dock tile: that field comes from the app store's catalogue, so a
plugin installed through the plugin system was reachable only by typing its url
or following the link on /plugins.
built at runtime rather than baked into the generated bundle, deliberately —
WHO sees a tile is a permission question, and a grant takes effect on the next
request rather than the next build. presentation comes from the manifest and the
route from mountPrefix, so there is one source for both, and is the
plugin's first permission so the endpoint can filter a tile out for an account
that cannot reach the screen.
two sources for tiles today, because the app store still has its own catalogue.
one when it is rebuilt on this.
the doc now records the system as complete rather than half-stubbed, including
the three bugs the extraction found — the sidecar-before-mount ordering, the
missing tailwind, and the build that could delete its own shell — and what is
genuinely still open.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
an exclusionary rule, made structural. a plugin does not render a screen: it
contributes panels and says how they are arranged, and the shell renders
WorkspaceView around them.
web/panels.ts appRegistryMetas — at least one panel
web/layout.ts defaultLayout — how they are arranged
both required the moment web/ exists, and missing either is refused at discovery
by name and with the reason. tested:
probeplug: has a web/ directory but is missing web/layout.ts.
Every plugin route renders a Workspace: contribute panels and a layout,
not a screen.
there is deliberately no way to export a component. one that could would be free
to render a bare div, a full-page form, or its own navigation, and the platform
would become a shell hosting strangers' layouts rather than one application.
non-compliance is not so much refused as unrepresentable — there is nowhere to
put a screen.
the shell registers <prefix> and <prefix>/:section, exactly as the core screens
do, so a plugin's sections stay addressable and cmd-clickable, and panels read
useParams independently rather than passing state between themselves.
appTypes.allowed is pinned to that plugin's own keys, so a persisted layout
naming something else falls back instead of rendering another plugin's panel
inside this screen.
the example plugin is rebuilt to model it — two panels, a layout, one of them
calling its own /api/example/ping through useClient — because the reference
implementation is what everyone copies.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
the plugin system works end to end for a plugin with an api/router.ts, at
runtime, with no restart. what is wired, what is not (schema push, the sidecar's
pm2 entry, websocket providers, totality across plugin routes), and what was
deliberately left: offscale is not extracted, because moving it deletes working
code across ~50 files and that wants someone watching.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
offscale is deliberately the simple case — one shared resource, read or write.
music is the next extraction and the right place to build the in-plugin
visibility system, because it has real per-user data (favourites, playlists,
now-playing) on top of a real shared one (a single global library index). so
'whose is this row' has a non-uniform answer there, where offscale's is just
'the owner's'.
not designed yet and deliberately not designed here. recorded so the intent
survives the gap.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
the platform's contract is what it already has: a role holds read or write on a
capability, stored in role_capabilities and enforced by the gate. anything
beyond — who sees whose rows, per-user isolation, record ownership, visibility
of any kind — is the plugin author's job, inside the plugin. the platform should
not grow machinery for it. a plugin knows what its data means; the platform only
knows whether this account got through the door.
offscale v1 uses that exactly. one shared resource: read sees what the owner
sees, write can change it including deleting a server the owner registered. that
is dangerous on purpose — the stored credential is a headscale admin key with no
read-only equivalent, so write is close to full control of the tailnet, and that
is the owner's call. expected use is read for most roles.
two consequences, both inside the plugin. the queries stop scoping by the caller
and resolve to the owner's id, leaving the per-user shape in the table unused as
the seam if isolation is ever wanted. and two POSTs are really reads —
/ssh-test probes and /policy/assist explicitly never saves — so they need
readOnlyWrites, or a read-level account finds a broken feature where a withheld
permission should be.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
offscale needs none of the install fields the catalogue carries — no modes, no
existingFields, no configFields, no composeTemplate, no members. nothing to
provision, nothing to point at. install is put the code there, push the schema,
start the sidecar, swap the routes, and it is available.
configuration happens afterwards inside the app, which is already how headscale
works: a server is registered at runtime and lands in offscale_servers.
so no-questions is the default rather than offscale's special case, and the
prompting machinery gets designed against the first extracted plugin that
actually needs docker or a remote instance. part of why this was the right
pilot — it exercises mounting, schema and sidecar without install being a
variable at the same time.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
the last gap. six ws providers live in bun's route table rather than hono's, so
the app swap does not reach them — but server.reload({routes}) does, and in both
directions: refused before, connected after install, refused again after
uninstall, with core routes untouched throughout.
so a plugin can own a socket from the start, and no part of an install needs the
process restarted.
still untested: whether connections already open across a reload survive it.
that matters before an install is allowed to interrupt somebody's terminal.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
this went round twice — runtime dynamic, then generated-plus-restart on the
belief that hono could not mount after serving, then back once that was actually
tested. the doc keeps the route rather than just the destination.
tested: SmartRouter (hono's default) and RegExpRouter both throw 'Can not add a
route since the matcher is already built'. TrieRouter and PatternRouter accept
it. so runtime adding is possible but costs the fast matcher, and hono has no
remove-route api at all, which uninstall needs.
what solves both is not adding routes but rebuilding: construct a fresh app from
the current plugin set and reassign the variable. the fetch closure reads it per
request, so the reassignment is the swap — atomic, no dropped connections, no
server.reload, and the default SmartRouter is kept. verified 404 before install,
200 after, 404 again after uninstall, with core routes unaffected throughout.
the mechanical cost is one line: server.tsx:322 is '/api/*': honoServer.fetch, a
bound method evaluated once at serve(), and has to become a closure or the swap
does nothing.
websockets stay open: six providers live in bun's route table rather than
hono's, so a plugin owning a socket needs server.reload({routes}), untested.
offscale has none.
and totality stops being a boot check — buildApp() is now the single place
routes are mounted, so it is where the assertion belongs, refusing the swap
rather than refusing the boot.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
this reverses the earlier decision for C (mount and unmount at runtime) and says
so rather than quietly overwriting it.
the requirement behind C was that the platform must not need to know a plugin in
advance. that is met either way: what it reads is a generated file listing the
installed routers, analogous to Plugins.tsx on the frontend — nothing hardcoded,
nothing read from a table at boot, the imports made concrete at install. C would
have bought only the absence of a restart.
and a restart is close to free here, because sidecars are pm2 peers rather than
children — a property that was fought for, since officer used to spawn the agent
and pm2's tree-kill took the owner's chat down on every restart. what a restart
costs is websockets, which reconnect, and in-memory session records, which
claude:list already recovers.
the happy consequence is that assertCapabilityTotality stays a boot check
instead of becoming a per-mount transaction. it does need to be fed the route
table rather than Object.keys(handlers) first — generated mounts widen that gap
rather than closing it, so that is a prerequisite and not a tidy-up beside it.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
pastilhas
